Highlights
- Bangladesh faces increasing heat waves, with 2024 recording temperatures of 40-42°C nationwide.
- Cloud seeding may offer a solution by enhancing precipitation and cooling effects.
- Cloud seeding introduces substances like silver iodide into clouds to stimulate ice crystal formation.
- Potential benefits include improved water resources, agriculture, and ecosystem health.
- Environmental risks include unintended ecological consequences and alteration of precipitation patterns.
- Bangladesh's readiness for cloud seeding depends on factors like meteorology, technology, regulations, and public acceptance.
Background
Bangladesh has been facing increasing heat waves during the summer over the last couple of years. 2024 is the hottest year yet, recording average temperatures of 40–42 °C in all districts. The population and biodiversity of the country are at stake because of such unprecedented catastrophes. Whether or not cloud seeding can mitigate this situation is a matter of discussion. In this article, I will explore what is cloud seeding, how it works, potential benefits, environmental risks and concerns, the global perspective, and the implementation of cloud seeding in Bangladesh.
What is cloud seeding?
Cloud seeding is a weather modification technique that aims to enhance precipitation by introducing substances into clouds to alter their microphysical processes. Various studies have been conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of cloud seeding in increasing precipitation. Silver iodide and dry ice are commonly used as cloud seeding agents due to their ability to act as ice nucleants, promoting the formation of ice crystals in clouds. The introduction of these seeding agents into clouds can lead to the production of ice crystals, which in turn can enhance precipitation.
Different methods of cloud seeding have been explored, such as using flares to produce hygroscopic particles in clouds or injecting hygroscopic particles into convective cells in warm stratocumulus clouds. Studies have shown that cloud seeding can lead to changes in cloud properties, precipitation intensity, and radar reflectivity, indicating the effectiveness of this technique in influencing weather patterns.
Cloud seeding can be achieved through various means, including using liquid carbon dioxide or silver iodide. Research has compared the effectiveness of these agents, with findings suggesting that liquid carbon dioxide may be more efficient for cloud seeding at certain atmospheric temperatures. Additionally, the deliberate injection of appropriate amounts of seeding agents into supercooled clouds can stimulate precipitation by enhancing ice crystal formation and growth, allowing for controlled artificial modification of clouds and precipitation.
Furthermore, secondary seeding has been proposed as a method to propagate seeding effects in space and time. This involves unseeded clouds ingesting ice particles from previously seeded clouds, potentially extending the impact of cloud seeding operations. Therefore, cloud seeding is a technique that shows promise in enhancing precipitation by modifying cloud microphysics. Research into different seeding agents, methods, and their effects on cloud properties and precipitation patterns contributes to a better understanding of the potential of cloud seeding as a tool for weather modification.
Potential benefits of cloud seeding
Cloud seeding is a weather modification technique designed to enhance precipitation in clouds primarily for agricultural and water resource management purposes. Although the environmental benefits of cloud seeding have been debated, there are potential positive impacts, particularly in specific contexts. There are several potential environmental benefits of this method.
Water Resource Management: Cloud seeding can augment water resources in areas experiencing water scarcity or drought conditions. Cloud seeding can bolster reservoir levels, groundwater recharge, and overall water availability by enhancing precipitation, particularly in regions heavily reliant on precipitation for the water supply.
Agricultural Benefits: Increased precipitation resulting from cloud seeding can improve agricultural productivity by providing sufficient water for crops during dry spells or drought periods. This can help to maintain soil moisture levels, support crop growth, and mitigate agricultural losses due to water stress.
Ecosystem Health: Improved precipitation through cloud seeding can help restore and maintain the health of natural ecosystems, including forests, wetlands, and grasslands. Adequate water availability is crucial to sustaining biodiversity, ecosystem services, and habitat integrity.
Fire Prevention and Control: In regions prone to wildfires, cloud seeding can potentially aid in fire prevention and control by promoting higher humidity levels and dampening fire-prone vegetation. By increasing precipitation, cloud seeding may reduce the likelihood and severity of wildfires, thereby safeguarding ecosystems and communities.
Air Quality Improvement: Enhanced precipitation resulting from cloud seeding can help alleviate air pollution by removing pollutants and particulate matter from the atmosphere. Rainfall can act as a natural cleanser, washing pollutants out of the air and contributing to improved air quality.
Mitigation of the Urban Heat Island Effect: Increased vegetation growth facilitated by cloud seeding, particularly in urban areas, can mitigate the urban heat island effect by providing shade, cooling surfaces, and moderating temperatures. This can enhance urban livability and reduce the energy consumption associated with cooling.
Climate Resilience: Cloud seeding may play a role in enhancing climate resilience by addressing water scarcity challenges and reducing the vulnerability of communities and ecosystems to climate-related risks such as droughts and heatwaves.
Environmental concerns and risks of cloud seeding
Despite the potential environmental benefits, cloud seeding also poses several environmental concerns and risks that warrant careful consideration:
Unintended Ecological Consequences: Introducing additional precipitation through cloud seeding can disrupt natural hydrological cycles and ecological processes, potentially leading to unintended consequences for ecosystems, including changes in species composition, habitat disruption, and alterations in ecosystem functioning.
Water Allocation and Equity Issues: Cloud seeding may exacerbate existing water allocation challenges and inequities by favoring certain regions or stakeholders. Concerns arise regarding the equitable distribution of water resources and the potential for conflict over water rights and access.
Chemical Use and Pollution: Some cloud seeding techniques involve the release of substances, such as silver iodide or liquid propane, which raises concerns about chemical pollution and their potential impacts on air and water quality, soil health, and aquatic ecosystems. Although studies suggest that the concentrations of these substances are typically low and below regulatory thresholds, their long-term environmental effects remain uncertain.
Alteration of Precipitation Patterns: Cloud seeding activities can potentially alter precipitation patterns and distribution, leading to changes in regional climate dynamics and weather systems. These alterations may have far-reaching consequences for agriculture, water resources, biodiversity, and natural hazards, such as floods and droughts.
Interference with natural processes: Cloud-seeding interventions may interfere with natural atmospheric processes and feedback mechanisms, potentially disrupting the balance between ecosystems and climatic systems. Artificial alteration of precipitation patterns could mask underlying environmental problems or delay the need for more sustainable solutions to water management and climate change adaptation.
Social and Ethical Considerations: Cloud seeding initiatives raise ethical questions regarding the manipulation of weather patterns and potential social implications, including issues related to governance, transparency, consent, and democratic decision-making processes. Stakeholder engagement and public participation are crucial for addressing concerns and ensuring accountability in cloud seeding programs.
Scientific Uncertainty and Efficacy: Despite decades of research and experimentation, a scientific understanding of cloud seeding effectiveness and its environmental impacts remains incomplete. Uncertainties persist regarding the efficacy of cloud seeding techniques under different meteorological conditions, scale of environmental effects, and long-term sustainability of cloud seeding interventions.
Global perspectives on cloud seeding
Several nations worldwide have implemented cloud seeding programs for various purposes, including enhancing precipitation, mitigating drought, and managing water resources. Some examples of countries known to have conducted cloud seeding initiatives include the following.
United States Cloud seeding has been practiced in several states across the U.S., including California, Texas, Colorado, and Utah, primarily for water resource management and snowpack augmentation.
China: China has one of the largest and most extensive cloud seeding programs globally, employing cloud seeding techniques for precipitation enhancement, particularly in regions prone to water scarcity and drought such as northern China.
United Arab Emirates (UAE): The UAE has invested in cloud-seeding technology as part of its efforts to address water security challenges in arid regions. Cloud seeding has been used to enhance rainfall and replenish reservoirs.
Australia: Cloud seeding has been utilized in parts of Australia, such as the Snowy Mountains region, to increase snowfall and water runoff for hydroelectric power generation and supply.
Russia: Russia has conducted cloud seeding experiments and programs in various regions, particularly Siberia and the Arctic, to study the potential for precipitation enhancement and weather modification.
Thailand: Thailand has implemented cloud-seeding projects to alleviate drought conditions and enhance agricultural productivity in rural areas. Cloud seeding has been employed in Indonesia, particularly in regions affected by forest fires and haze, as a measure to induce rainfall and mitigate fire risks.
India: India has successfully tested this technology.
Is Bangladesh ready to implement cloud seeding?
Determining whether Bangladesh is ready to implement cloud seeding requires a comprehensive assessment of various factors, including meteorological conditions, technological capabilities, regulatory frameworks, socioeconomic considerations, and public acceptance. Key considerations for evaluating Bangladesh's readiness for cloud seeding implementation are as follows:
Meteorological Conditions: Bangladesh's climate, characterized by a monsoon season and high humidity levels, may present favorable conditions for cloud seeding. However, the effectiveness of cloud seeding depends on local atmospheric dynamics, cloud formation processes, and precipitation patterns, which must be thoroughly studied and understood.
Technological capabilities: Assessing Bangladeshi technological infrastructure and capabilities to conduct cloud seeding operations is crucial. This includes the availability of aircraft or ground-based seeding generators, expertise in weather forecasting and cloud physics, and access to seeding agents, such as silver iodide.
Regulatory Frameworks: Establishing robust regulatory frameworks and governance mechanisms is essential for overseeing cloud seeding activities, ensuring compliance with environmental standards, and addressing potential risks and concerns. Clear guidelines for the licensing, monitoring, and evaluation of cloud seeding programs are necessary to safeguard environmental and public health.
Socioeconomic Considerations: Evaluating the socioeconomic impacts of cloud seeding is critical, considering factors such as water resource management, agricultural productivity, and disaster risk reduction. Stakeholder engagement, including consultations with local communities, farmers, and relevant sectors, can help assess the potential benefits and risks of cloud-seeding initiatives.
Public Acceptance and Awareness: Public acceptance and awareness of cloud seeding are vital for successful implementation. Effective communication strategies, transparency in decision-making processes, and public education initiatives can foster understanding and trust among the population regarding the objectives, methods, and implications of cloud-seeding activities.
International Collaboration: Collaboration with international partners, research institutions, and meteorological organizations can provide valuable expertise, resources, and best practices for implementing cloud seeding programs in Bangladesh. Knowledge exchange and capacity-building initiatives can enhance local capabilities and promote sustainable weather modification approaches.
Recommendations
Comprehensive Feasibility Study: A comprehensive feasibility study should be conducted to assess the suitability of cloud seeding under the climatic conditions of Bangladesh. This study should evaluate meteorological factors, technological requirements, environmental impacts, and socioeconomic considerations.
Investment in technological infrastructure: Investment in the necessary technological infrastructure for cloud seeding operations, including aircraft or ground-based seeding generators, weather monitoring equipment, and expertise in cloud physics and meteorology.
Establishment of Regulatory Frameworks: Develop robust regulatory frameworks and governance mechanisms to oversee cloud seeding activities, ensure compliance with environmental standards, and address potential risks and concerns. This should include licensing, monitoring, and evaluation of protocols.
Stakeholder Engagement and Public Awareness: Engage stakeholders, including government agencies, research institutions, local communities, and civil society organizations, in the decision-making process regarding cloud seeding. Raise public awareness through education campaigns to foster the understanding and acceptance of cloud seeding initiatives.
Pilot Projects and Research: Initiate pilot projects and research studies to evaluate the effectiveness, environmental impacts, and socioeconomic benefits of cloud seeding in Bangladesh. These projects can provide valuable insights and data to inform future decision-making and scaling up of cloud seeding operations.
International Collaboration: Foster collaboration with international partners, research institutions, and meteorological organizations to leverage expertise, resources, and best practices in cloud seeding. This collaboration can support capacity-building efforts and enhance Bangladesh's capabilities for weather modification and climate adaptation.
By following these recommendations, Bangladesh can strategically explore the potential of cloud seeding as a tool to enhance precipitation, mitigate heatwaves, and address water resource challenges, thereby contributing to the country's resilience to climate change and promoting sustainable development.
References
Chen, B. and Yin, Y. (2014). Can we modify stratospheric water vapor by deliberate cloud seeding?. Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres, 119(3), 1406-1418. https://doi.org/10.1002/2013jd020707
French, J., Friedrich, K., Tessendorf, S., Rauber, R., Geerts, B., Rasmussen, R., … & Blestrud, D. (2018). Precipitation formation from orographic cloud seeding. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 115(6), 1168-1173. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1716995115
Givati, A. (2005). Separation between cloud-seeding and air-pollution effects. Journal of Applied Meteorology, 44(9), 1298-1314. https://doi.org/10.1175/jam2276.1
Jung, E., Albrecht, B., Jonsson, H., Chen, Y., Seinfeld, J., Sorooshian, A., … & Russell, L. (2015). Precipitation effects of giant cloud condensation nuclei artificially introduced into stratocumulus clouds. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 15(10), 5645-5658. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-15-5645-2015
Jung, W., Cha, J., Ko, A., Chae, S., Ro, Y., Hwang, H., … & Lee, C. (2022). Progressive and prospective technology for cloud seeding experiment by unmanned aerial vehicle and atmospheric research aircraft in korea. Advances in Meteorology, 2022, 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/3128657
Maryadi, A., Tomine, K., & Nishiyama, K. (2015). Some aspects of a numerical glaciogenic artificial cloud seeding experiment using liquid carbon dioxide over kupang, indonesia. Journal of Agricultural Meteorology, 71(1), 1-14. https://doi.org/10.2480/agrmet.d-14-00038
Seto, J., Tomine, K., Wakimizu, K., & Nishiyama, K. (2011). Artificial cloud seeding using liquid carbon dioxide: comparisons of experimental data and numerical analyses. Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology, 50(7), 1417-1431. https://doi.org/10.1175/2011jamc2592.1
Wang, F., Li, Z., Qi, J., Wang, G., Jia, S., Duan, J., … & Zhou, Y. (2019). Evaluation of hygroscopic cloud seeding in liquid-water clouds: a feasibility study. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 19(23), 14967-14977. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-19-14967-2019
Woodley, W. (2018). Secondary seeding as a means of propagating seeding effects in space and time. The Journal of Weather Modification, 34(1), 31-38. https://doi.org/10.54782/jwm.v34i1.232